Winter is menswear’s power season. Yet when thermometers start icing over, most men banish sartorial thoughts and instead grab the nearest, fluffiest item in the hopes of staying toasty. Error. More clothes means more opportunity for making a positive statement.

To make sure that statement isn’t offensive, we’ve identified seven cold-weather pieces no self-respecting man should have in his wardrobe, and offer suggestions on what to replace them with.

The Culprit: Bobble Hats

Bobble hats may be acceptable chalet wear, but away from the slopes the bobble is an instant dignity-robber for any self-respecting man.

Now the domain of children and hipsters, anyone trying to look a cut above should steer clear of extraneous head appendages.

The culprit: bobble hats

The Innocent: Sleek Beanies

After you’ve burned the bobble, don’t settle for a hat that makes you look like a skater boy. “The beanie is an incredibly versatile accessory that every man should own,” says Robyn Ferris, menswear buyer for Mr Porter. “A subtle pattern like a fleck or Fair Isle on a thick ribbed beanie should provide just enough visual quirk without you having to look like Where’s Wally.”

Avoid garish logos and absolutely no peaks. In terms of colour, Ferris recommends solid olive green or deep navy. The ideal length is snug around the top of your ears and slightly looser at the back – too tight and it’ll look like a prophylactic.

The innocent: sleek beanies

Key Pieces

  • M&s Collection Ribbed Beanie HatM&s Collection Ribbed Beanie Hat
  • J.crew Melange Knitted BeanieJ.crew Melange Knitted Beanie
  • Thom Browne Camel BeanieThom Browne Camel Beanie
  • Selected Homme Cable Knit BeanieSelected Homme Cable Knit Beanie
  • Reiss Nake Cable Knit Beanie Hat NavyReiss Nake Cable Knit Beanie Hat Navy
  • Topman Khaki And Black Mini Ribbed Roll BeanieTopman Khaki And Black Mini Ribbed Roll Beanie

The Culprit: Shiny Puffy Jackets

The glossy puffa is reminiscent of Eastenders’ Bianca Jackson – not a regular on most designers’ mood boards.

“The puffa jacket is having something of a moment right now, but there’s nothing worse than a shiny one,” says Ferris. Not only do they make you look like a walking fire hazard, padded jackets do nothing for your silhouette either. Most men need to elongate their physiques; the puffa conspires to do the opposite, its bulk forcing you to struggle into pockets and through doorways.

The culprit: Shiny puffy jackets

The Innocent: Smart Layering

Although less garish quilted options are available, layering will often do away with the need for such offences altogether.

“A shirt, chunky knit and decent leather jacket will keep you looking good as well as warm,” says fashion blogger Michael Adams, aka Michael84. For smarter occasions, a cashmere jumper over an Oxford shirt, combined with a blazer, scarf and pea coat, will do the trick without conjuring the Ghostbusters marshmallow man.

For those situations where only a proper outdoors coat will do, try a matte down-filled parka from an outdoors specialist like Canada Goose, Woolrich or Penfield.

The innocent: smart layers

The Culprit: Snoods

Another ski-bum staple (are you starting to see a pattern?), the snood is the epitome of lazywear; the symbol of a man so mellow that rather than bother with the conundrum of scarf knot choices, he decides to eliminate the middleman altogether and staple the ends to each other.

Unfortunately, the snood screams student or burnout, regardless of how much formalwear you pair it with.

The culprit: snoods

The Innocent: Subtle Pattern Scarves

Before we delve into ‘what does your scarf knot say about you’ territory, remember that scarves can create different looks; looped through to bulk out a pea coat in colder weather or left loose hanging under a blazer to inject life into staid formalwear.

A subdued tartan pattern or similar, such as this Barbour merino-cashmere piece, will introduce a subtle touch of colour to your outfit and fortify your torso against the chill.

The innocent: subtle pattern scarves

Key Pieces

  • Reiss Hamish Checked Wool ScarfReiss Hamish Checked Wool Scarf
  • John Lewis Horizontal Stripe Cashmink ScarfJohn Lewis Horizontal Stripe Cashmink Scarf
  • Navy Check Cashmere And Merino ScarfNavy Check Cashmere And Merino Scarf
  • Barbour Merino Cashmere Tartan ScarfBarbour Merino Cashmere Tartan Scarf
  • Polo Ralph Lauren Loden Plaid Wool-blend ScarfPolo Ralph Lauren Loden Plaid Wool-blend Scarf
  • Paul Smith Striped Lambswool ScarfPaul Smith Striped Lambswool Scarf

The Culprit: Shearling Boots

As the current trend for suede and shearling spills over into shoes, winter boots are starting to look more like Uggs, the uniform of Starbucks-dwelling single girls everywhere.

It’s a headturner for all the wrong reasons; when you want a classic look, you’re actually getting classless.

The culprit: shearling boots

The Innocent: Brogue Boots

“Many brands are now offering more stylised options with subtle touches of shearling added to streamlined silhouettes,” says Ferris. “I’m a big fan of Edward Green’s Nevis boots.”

Alternatively, if you want to steer clear of sheepskin altogether, leather brogue boots are a foolproof addition to your shoe rack that will work year-round with both denim and tailoring.

The innocent: brogue boots

Key Pieces

  • H By Hudson Sadler Black Brogue BootsH By Hudson Sadler Black Brogue Boots
  • Ben Sherman Brogue BootsBen Sherman Brogue Boots
  • Frank Wright Brogue BootsFrank Wright Brogue Boots
  • Oliver Sweeney Airton Leather Brogue BootsOliver Sweeney Airton Leather Brogue Boots
  • Trickers Commando Sole Malton Brogue Derby BootTrickers Commando Sole Malton Brogue Derby Boot
  • Ted Baker Sealls Combination Brogue BootTed Baker Sealls Combination Brogue Boot

The Culprit: Novelty Christmas Jumpers

Whether it’s a Santa-suit Primark monstrosity or matching his ‘n’ hers knits, showing off these eyesores anywhere other than a Christmas do is a hanging offence.

Although we understand the temptation to get more wear out of a once-a-year purchase, take our advice: don’t.

The culprit: Novelty Christmas jumpers

The Innocent: Fair Isle Knits

A dark, well-made knit with a horizontal pattern is fun enough to join in the Christmas party and get a bit of wear out on the streets in winter.

Ferris recommends examining designers such as Alexander Wang, who’ve begun to embrace Fair Isle prints, albeit with a modern spin. This eye-catching option from the AW15 collection is bright and festive, but can be worn to the pub without shame.

The innocent: patterned knits

Key Pieces

  • Norse Projects Birnir Fair Isle Alpaca KnitNorse Projects Birnir Fair Isle Alpaca Knit
  • Alexander Wang Mens Fairisle Jacquard Crew Neck KnitAlexander Wang Mens Fairisle Jacquard Crew Neck Knit
  • J.crew Fair Isle Wool-blend SweaterJ.crew Fair Isle Wool-blend Sweater
  • He By Mango Bicolor Jacquard SweaterHe By Mango Bicolor Jacquard Sweater
  • Lyle & Scott Block Fair Isle JumperLyle & Scott Block Fair Isle Jumper
  • Woolrich Jacquard Crew KnitWoolrich Jacquard Crew Knit

The Culprit: Bright Windbreakers

Are you going for a run? No? Then you must be going camping. By the very name windbreakers scream functionality. They do a job and they do it well, but like so many of the most useful things in the world, they don’t often look good doing it.

Those two-tone dayglo hues are great for being spotted on the moors. Less so at fashion week.

The culprit: bright windbreakers

The Innocent: Windbreakers In Disguise

Fortunately, brands have cottoned on to the utilitarian nature of performance fabrics and incorporated them into better-looking pieces.

Levi’s, Stone Island and Baracuta are just some of the labels offering up stylish bombers, track jackets and Harringtons in water- and windproof materials this season, which are able to cope with whatever Mother Nature throws at them.

The innocent: windbreakers in disguise

Key Pieces

  • Levis Windbomber 3.0Levis Windbomber 3.0
  • Baracuta 3layers G9 Jacket – Windbreaker TwistBaracuta 3layers G9 Jacket - Windbreaker Twist
  • Folk Gabardine Bomber JacketFolk Gabardine Bomber Jacket
  • A.p.c. Lieutenant Bomber JacketA.p.c. Lieutenant Bomber Jacket
  • Stone Island David Jersey-tc Bomber JacketStone Island David Jersey-tc Bomber Jacket
  • Barbour International Bonnar Wax JacketBarbour International Bonnar Wax Jacket

The Culprit: Hooded Gilets

When it comes to high-end menswear, style often takes precedence over substance. But rarely is that truer than with the hooded gilet.

At least normal sleeveless hoodies – while unappealing as a fashion statement – serve a purpose when working out. But hooded gilets, especially those in solid bright colours, continue to linger on through winter like a cold-sore.

The culprit: Hooded gilets

The Innocent: Transitional Jackets

When big coats are too warm, the solution isn’t to chop the arms off. Instead, layering lets you bundle up without looking bundled up.

Lightweight, unlined coats – from macs and trenches to parkas and field jackets – will slot over knits to keep you weatherproof without a) sweating or b) looking like a Young Conservative.

The innocent: midweight jackets

  • Mki Plain Coach JacketMki Plain Coach Jacket
  • Reiss Grafton Concealed Placket MacReiss Grafton Concealed Placket Mac
  • He By Mango Nylon Field JacketHe By Mango Nylon Field Jacket
  • Uniqlo Men Mountain ParkaUniqlo Men Mountain Parka
  • Topman Dark Indigo Western Denim JacketTopman Dark Indigo Western Denim Jacket
  • Stone Island Cotton-blend OvershirtStone Island Cotton-blend Overshirt

Final Word

So, do you agree with our list? Any other winter eyesores we’ve missed?

Let us know in the comments section below.