Which Coat?

Hi! I'm 18 years old and I'm starting to change my wardrobe into something a little smarter; think Joseph Gordon-Levitt in (500) Days of Summer, but occasionally wearing bright colours. Anyway, at the moment I'm looking around for a winter coat. I'm a starving student, so my budget's pretty low, however I understand the need for quality. I've seen two rather different coats I like, both on quite good reductions, and I'm having a hard time deciding between the two of them.

The first one is from All Saints:
http://images.allsaints.com/download...515-2438-1.jpg

And the second one is from Austin Reed:
http://resources.shopstyle.co.uk/pim...d1826a81bd.jpg
(apologies for the small photo, this is the link to see it on the website: AR RED Navy Trench Coat - Casual Coats - Austin Reed)

Any input would be greatly appreciated!

Much prefer the 1st one - The belt on the 2nd makes it look like a bit like a bath robe imo

The All Saints one will be much more durable and versatile, and is just generally nicer.

The AR one isn't so much of a warm winter coat, I'd go with the All Saints one.

Thanks very much for your responses guys, the All Saints one has been ordered!

Where have you ordered that coat from, can't find it on Allsaints.

I got it from eBay, someone was selling it new with tags for quite cheap. They've called it a 'Herz Pea Coat' but I just did a quick search on eBay and there doesn't seem to be any others on there.

I have got a very similar one from All Saints and it's lovely - fits well, very warm, good quality, really versatile, so you have chosen well chap

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ATP

I got it from eBay, someone was selling it new with tags for quite cheap. They've called it a 'Herz Pea Coat' but I just did a quick search on eBay and there doesn't seem to be any others on there.

---

How much did you pay?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Pin Money

How much did you pay?

---

They were selling it for £200 but I got it for £150.