Y'see, I think these are the two best photos of all you've linked. Take the hat off the first guy, and the outfit is a straightforward, well-coordinated smart/casual look.
And while I think the second guy looks a bit of a turnip, the shoes, suit and shirt I'd wear (although that suit is fecking expensive, I'm guessing).
Anyway, I dress more like those guys on a day to day basis than any of the other photos that were linked. To say it's overdone when I see far more folks dressed like in the OP doesn't chime with my experience at all.

