• Men's Fashion

The Perfect Mitten: How Humanity Figured It Out 300 Years Ago

The World’s Oldest Mittens

The humble mitten. One of the objects humanity has really not improved for ever. These are some of the oldest intact mittens ever found. They belong to a child in Iceland around the year 900. You can tell they were for a child because even 1100 years ago, parents were like, “Okay, you lost the mittens.” Not a Nope. Mommy’s not mad at all. You used your super sight and couldn’t find them. And you Okay, today we are focused on two of the most famous forms of mittens ever created. The yellow mitten and the ice mitten, for lack of a better term.

 

Testing the Ice Mitten

We shall begin by testing one of them. Ambient temperature outside 30° on the dot. But for today’s purposes, we care specifically about the temperature of the water. Okay, small problem with our experiment. I am currently standing on the river that I wanted to test the temperature of. Brat. Okay, that’s we’ll find other water. I think I saw a little puddle somewhere else. Stupid stupid Michael didn’t think the It’s just simple math. If the temperature thought you had such a good idea before you check the temperature in the morning before you go outside. Ambient temperature outside 30° temperature of the water. 34.2° Fahrenheit 1.2° C. Okay, not as climactic as I envisioned, but here we go.

These are Duckstein mittens. Loved by ice climbers because they’re extremely warm, wind-resistant, water resistant, and flexible. Some climbers say they don’t get good until they get an ice skin on them from climbing all day. Fishermen also did something very similar with their mittens. Yeah.

New England fisherman’s wives would knit their husbands a pair of mittens that were about 30% too big for their hands. Then every single day that fisherman on his way steaming out would get his mittens soaking wet in warm water and stomp on them on the deck until they shrunk down to the correct size. I’m trying to do that with these right now. Hopefully you could see the size difference.

The Warmest Wool Mittens Ever Made

Felted wool mittens are some of the thickest, warmest wool mittens that you could possibly make. But they’re not the warmest wool mittens you can make. The warmest knit wool mittens probably came in the 19th century in Aderondex, Maine, Massachusetts, or Vermont. They were called buff mittens or shag mittens. Very, very cool.

There’s not a lot of information about them. There’s sparse pictures and paintings that show a buff mitten on the ground or something like that. They’re in museums. There’s stuff like that about them. And I have a pair. I found them on eBay for 100 bucks and I bought them and I’m going to donate them to a museum. How cool is that?

The Legendary Yellow Mitten

That is one type of extremely famous, super popular mittens that you see everywhere. But there’s another type of mitten that is even more popular that is very, very famous in Minnesota, in Wisconsin, in South Dakota, in Maine that I am going to put on my hand right now, but the thumb is a little mispositioned. The extremely famous and legendary yellow mitten. What’s so great about it? Why does everybody in Minnesota and Canada and all the really cold places wear it? And why is it so warm?

Those two styles of mittens set the formula for mittens forever. They’ve never changed. This style of mitten is around 300 years old. And why haven’t they changed? Well, 300 years ago, something happened that basically made it so the perfect mitten was figured out. Before that, there were two different ones. And then there was one. And so we will be splitting the perfect mitten up into its two halves and dissecting each one. I broke this article into three easy to digest parts.

Who Put the Yellow in These Yellow Mittens?

I’m wearing two different mittens for a very important reason. This is the gold standard and yellow mitten material. This is the modern version. We use this modern version because it’s a lot cheaper and almost as effective, but it’s not as good as the original. As you could probably see, the leather between the two looks very different.

Indigenous people in northern areas wrote the rule book on leather mittens. We have the Inuit, the Upupic, the Sami Alaskan Native um creed to the world of mittens. They wrote the rule book on what makes a good mitten because they did not change quality for big machines or anything like that. So their stuff was insane.

If we start with the Inuit people, they are masters at making a double-layered mitten called the pualloo. That’s a very important mitten with seal skin on the outside, caribou hide on the inside with the first still facing your hand. The Inuit people because of where they lived and the materials they had around them had to process leather in a very very specific and intensive way. They were scraping fat and blubber and everything off from seals. They had to actually chew the leather to make it soft enough to work with.

Obviously, that got superseded by machines that now use metal teeth to mimic the same thing going on. But the thing to note is that they got their insulation from the actual leather itself. They left the hair on the caribou to keep their hands warm. They didn’t put something else in the mittens on those double mittens.

The Anishinaabe People and Buckskin

Now, if we go south from that and we focus on the Anishianab people, which by the way, if I say something wrong or something like that, I researched, practiced pronunciation as hard as I possibly could. Not perfect. Sorry if there’s a mistake. The Anisha people and tribes around the Great Lakes focused on deer skin, moose, elk, which all of those are premier glove leathers like this right here.

This is buck skin. The characteristics of buck skin and elk and moose and everything combined with the way it was processed make it extremely soft, very stretchy, silent when you’re moving around. So if you’re hunting, it doesn’t creek. Breathable, easy to repair. Because the leather is so soft, it was easy to pierce. And most importantly, in the winter, well, I guess in general, if it got wet, it didn’t stiffen up over time, so it always stayed soft, pliable, and stretchy. It’s really great for what you needed.

All of these hides that were tanned and processed in the traditional way were legendary because of all the work it actually took to make them. You had to agitate the leather as it was tanning. Then you had to put it over smoke so that way it didn’t stiffen up and harden because it broke down all the fibers inside so they didn’t glue together. It took a lot of time and because of the characteristics of buckskin moose and elk, it also took an expert to say, “Okay, this leather is a little stretchier here. This one is soft like this. This one’s a little drier. So I need to process it this way.” Exactly. But it paid off in spades.

Why Are They Yellow?

All these leathers are yellow because of the smoking process that I talked about before. When the leather was first processed, it was basically white and then the smoke turned it this color. And I’m assuming by the time that these were sold in places like Sears and stuff like that, with the first version being seen in 1902, it could have been sold before that, but there’s not a lot of records of it. By that time, people associated the color yellow with buckskin mittens and good quality. So manufacturers dyed their stuff yellow to match. I would assume.

Obviously now in 2026 with modern tanning processes and machines that can agitate stuff and things like that, usually the gap is almost closed. Buck skin is still probably a superior leather, but cowhide is way cheaper, way easier to get, way easier to work with. And this is soft, treated to be very water resistant, tough, durable, and more consistent throughout. Pigkin is also another alternative that is used that is very soft, has similar qualities to buck skin and stuff like that, but obviously way cheaper because a lot more people eat pork and stuff like that.

The Inside of the Mitten: Wool vs. Leather

So, the yellow mitten was considered to be the gold standard of quality. But the reason that I mentioned the paloo is because of the insulation that goes inside of the mitten. We have the gold standard of the outside of the mitten, but the inside is not so easy. Actually, I shouldn’t put it like that. There were many, many, many solutions. You could stuff the mittens with grasses or buffalo down like the undercoat of a buffalo, which is incredibly warm.

Or you could just use animal hides and furs themselves to keep your hands warm. But if you combine the perfect mitten outer with a specific little animal that bounces around, in some cases eats kelp, and other cases eats alalfa and other things, you get kind of the world’s most loved mitten. The mitten that everybody likes, the yellow most famous Minnesota mitten. I’m saying Minnesota, obviously. We’ll get It’s not just Minnesota, but we’ll get there in a second.

People that had sheep absolutely loved sheep. And while of course everybody was kind of working on leather at the same time, if you had sheep available to you, you were like, “Let’s not focus solely on leather, let’s put a lot of thought into this.” People that have a ton of sheep’s wool are figuring out how can we develop the best, strongest, most durable mittens possible. And people with a ton of leather are figuring out the same thing, but with their materials that are more readily accessible to them.

But they both have downsides. Naturally insulating. It’s warm immediately, you don’t need to add anything else. Also very good when it’s wet. It keeps your hand warm, but if you’re swinging an axe or doing crazy work, not very durable, so you need to keep remaking these all of the time. On the other hand, we have something that is not naturally insulating, but very, very durable. Windproof, not so good in the water, but still doesn’t creek and freeze up if it gets wet.

The Birth of the Chopper Mitten

So now, if we fast forward to the 1700s and the 1800s in the US specifically, is similar stuff is actually happening around the world. The Sami people were combining their reindeer outers with knit iners. But we have a massive logging industry in the US where people are swinging axes all day long. They need something to protect their hands and to keep them warm. We also have knitting everywhere. It’s cheap, it’s fast, you can do it at home. You can make mittens all day long.

So, we make an over mitten like the paloo, but with different materials. This helps you grip an axe, protects your hands. Also, you can take this off or if a machine grabs your hand, this comes off and you still have this mitten underneath it. So if you need to vent your hands during the day but not freeze them off, you have wool.

And at the end of the day, you take the wool mittens, you put them by the stove, they dry off for the next day, or you rotate the mittens out. So what do you call your mittens? Choppers. This is a chopper mitten. These are choppers. LLBAN ones are choppers. Technically, the M49 US Arctic Extreme cold mittens choppers.

Watch This Article

300 Years Later, the Formula Hasn’t Changed

Look at how insanely far we have come in leather mitten technology. We have strategic leather reinforcements all over the mittens so you can hold ski poles.

We have this lobster claw that was originally made so you can shoot a gun easier. Neoprene cuffs, really cool applied logo things. But through all of that and with all of that, at the end of the day, we’re still just following that same formula of wool or synthetic material nowadays and leather. For 300 years, we haven’t come up with something that’s better for most people.

This article was adapted from Michael Kristy’s video on The Iron Snail, with edits from FashionBeans, and was reviewed by Michael to ensure the integrity of his original content. Watch the full video here.