Shirt on Shirt
At FashionBeans, we are big fans of giving our readers a heads up on what to expect for the season to come. It gives everyone a chance to have a good hard think about what trends and looks they want to incorporate into their style, before actually being knee deep in said season.
However, there is another aspect of a coming season that we, as writers, never really mention. And that is what looks or trends we are personally looking to try out and test this time around. As we all know, what’s ‘in’ this season doesn’t always sit well with all the people all the time. Just take a look at any of our comments sections to see what I’m talking about.
So this time around I decided that rather than bashing out yet another ‘Top 5 Items/Looks for AW12′, I’d let you guys have a little bit of an insight into what I intend to be rocking this season, outside of the realm of my extremely streamlined wardrobe of men’s fashion basics.
The Overshirt
For autumn/winter 2012, that would the overshirt. Or perhaps it would more appropriate to say ‘shirt on shirt’ – because I am not talking about a shacket here at all. Not that I have anything against them, I’m just specifically talking about wearing two shirts on top of each other.
The inspiration came a few months back, when I was looking at some old black and white school photos from 1940s/1950s New York. Nearly every picture I looked at featured someone from a blue collar/working class background wearing a shirt and tie with another heavier shirt loosely buttoned over the top. It was perfect for the coming autumn, when the weather has yet to turn freezing but you still require that extra layer for warmth.
The Guidelines
But, as always, there are a few rules I’ll have to follow (and you too if you fancy it):
- Thin to thick – remember to layer your clothes in order of thickness. So the overshirt should be of a thicker material than your inside shirt.
- Knot it – speaking of the inside shirt, it should always be of a more crisp, pristine nature and knotted with a tie. Trust me, I’ve tested it out and it always looks better this way.
- Stay true to size – don’t size up for the outer layer! Buy your usual size and you’ll be surprised how much room there is to layer.
- Remember your history – this look is heavily rooted in a workerwear background, so try to pair it with more casual, workerwear pieces such as chinos, flannel trousers and boots.
- Have fun – you’re going for an unconventional look so why not have a bit of fun by playing with colour (albeit autumnal ones), texture and maybe even throw a bow tie in the mix?
Example Looks
Here are three example looks that I will be rocking come October. These would also be a good starting place for anyone wanting to try out this particular look:
Look 1
By now you should all own a lightweight blue chambray shirt. Pair this with some navy chinos and a blue and red striped bow tie and you’ve already got a solid preppy look in itself. However, throw an overshirt on top and you’ve got a whole new beast on your hands.
Pick up a flannel or cashmere-blend plaid shirt in a complementing colour such as purple, red or mustard yellow and leave the top three buttons undone. Then all you need is a tweed drivers cap (or snap back hats for those of you out there) and some brown suede desert boots:
- Folk Chambray 3 Button Collar Shirt

- Reiss Zackery Long Sleeve Denim Look Shirt Blue

- J.crew Cotton-chambray Shirt

- Uniqlo Men Flannel Check Long Sleeve Shirt Bd

- Suit Red Check Luther Flannel Shirt

- Marc By Marc Jacobs Plaid Cotton-flannel Shirt

- Lock & Co Hatters Herringbone Wool Flat Cap

- Reiss Wickham Pressed Chinos Navy

- Asos Desert Boots In Suede

Look 2
Why not just inverse the look? Pick up a broadcloth check shirt in a rich autumnal colour such as scarlet, olive or a deep brown and pair it with a thicker denim overshirt.
Give a nod to the coming cold weather with a herringbone necktie and a pair of grey wool dress trousers. Top the whole thing off with a pair of burgundy brogue boots:
- Ami Slim-fit Check Cotton Shirt

- Uniqlo Men Extra Fine Cotton Broadcloth Check Long Sleeve Shirt W

- Uniqlo Men Extra Fine Cotton Broadcloth Check Long Sleeve Shirt P

- Polo Ralph Lauren Shirt In Slim Fit Denim

- Allsaints Bronson Shirt

- Acne Isherwood Button-down Collar Denim Shirt

- Ted Baker Herbarc – Herringbone Tie

- Farah Vintage Slim Trouser In Wool Mix

- Mr. Hare Freud Textured-panel Leather Boots

Look 3
Ever wondered what purpose a corduroy shirt could possibly have? Well, it works pretty well within this look.
Go for a contrasting colour shirt combination such as red and blue or green and yellow but change the hues. For example, a pink button down Oxford cloth under a navy corduroy over shirt with a knitted brown tie would look perfect.
Pair this one with some raw selvedge jeans and some brown double monks for the perfect weekend look. This can easily transition into a evening look by swapping the overshirt for a navy blazer, losing the tie and swapping the Dub’s for some black loafers.
- Topman Plum Washed Oxford Shirt

- Polo Ralph Lauren Plain Oxford Slim Fit Shirt

- Farah Vintage Sky Blue Hudson Shirt

- Allsaints Sorley Shirt

- Lee 101 Shirt Cord

- Aspesi Button-down Collar Fine-corduroy Shirt

- Polo Ralph Lauren One Rinse Varick Straight Jeans

- John Lobb William Leather Monk-strap Shoes

- Bass Weejun Black Larson Loafer

Final Word
So there you have it guys, the main look I’m going to be attempting this AW12.
Before you all jump to the comments section to politely inform me how misinformed I am with trying this look out, why not first share what looks and trends you are going to try out this coming season? Or maybe what essential items you’re looking to purchase this time around.
Let me know guys!
Matt Allinson
Men’s Guide To Business-Casual – The Summer Edition
Men’s Fashion Basics – Part 93 – What Tailoring A Suit Can Do For You
Spring/Summer Essential Fabrics – Part 1: Linen
Men's Short Hairstyles
Men's Mid-length Hairstyles
Men's Long Hairstyles
Men's Curly Hairstyles
Men's Black & Afro Hairstyles
Celebrity Hairstyles
AllSaints Earlham Street Screening Room
Style Inspiration: Monaco Chic
Celluloid Style: The Great Gatsby (1974)
Style Inspiration: Berlin Grunge






























I might try this as an alternative to the denim shirt/jacket + tee combo.
It’s a shame there are no pictures of the actual look.
Unfortunately we couldn’t find enough within current collections and lookbooks. I think you will see a lot more of the look within new AW12 lookbooks going forward however.
I will no doubt be trying this as it turns a little colder and less stuffy. I’ll be looking forward to mixing obscure colours. But – I’ll disagree with you in that oversized wouldn’t be something to try out. I’ve been using large silk shirts over teeshirts or just on their own this summer for a more romantic look, and no one seems to have taken oversized seriously, Except low crotch baggy chinos – omw that should never happen. My point got lost somewhere in there…. oversized is a great way to add texture and give a much softer silhouette which is great for summer.
I’ll be looking to get – should I be able to scrape up enough on a students budget – some beautiful monk straps by Grenson for this autumn. They are awe inspiring. Im still feeling tweed and I think I’ll be able to pull it off without looking ‘last year’.
Only a matter of time before we start layering trousers ey? ^^
I think you can layer two shorts, and go bigger on the second. The oversized look is defiantly this AW12. We see from one of the frontman articles, that the lead singer Orlando weeks (look.3) layers up very effectively with this style. I have been using it already, and been pleasantly surprised with the expressions from people.
Please reply with your thoughts.
where’s the look besides the intro pic?
Wouldn’t it be better to wear a granddad style shirt and a collared shirt together? Two collars is much busier and distracting to me.
Grandad collar is certainly an option. But i think if you are going to try it, then why not go all out? You can lose the tie if it seems to much for a more casual take on the look.
Been doing this for ages. Finally I’m cool.
Pretty useless article without style pics.
here you are Smurf –
http://www.thestyleblogger.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/reIMG_8039.jpg
http://marrowmag.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/hunting-shirt-3sixteen-pendleton-overshirt-by-3sixteen-chunky-knit-cap.jpg
plus a few of the looks from this lookbook give a rough idea too – http://goodhoodstore.com/?page=41&id=291
Like this look have thought about it in the past as i have an all saints denim shirt i wear as a sort of denim jacket.
my question is although thicker in reality a oxford underneath would that work? i have a pale blue one feel may work
A white round neck, with the all saints denim shirt/ jacket on top, then a nice all saints styled leather jacket on top of that dressed with skinny jeans and desert boots.
What about tucking in? Should both shirts be untucked, or perhaps the lower shirt tucked in and the out shirt not?
How about wearing the overshirt completely unbuttoned?